Candidates and Constituency Assessments


saltire shield'Few Telegraph readers will have been surprised to find Councillors McPherson and Mackie rushing to the defence of Jill ShimiÕs petulant attack on Joe FitzPatrick. They are, after all, the leaders of the Lib Dem and Tory minority groups on Dundee City Council and keep Jill Shimi in her post as Leader of the Administration. Both these groups have been well rewarded for their deference to the Labour Party with convenerships and special responsibility allowances worth tens of thousands of pounds each year. Councillor Shimi may be facing an electoral disaster of her own making but at least she can take comfort in the fact she is getting value for money from her political stooges.'
Kenneth Guild in the Evening Telegraph, 3 rd October 2006.
Lion Rampant

Dundee West (North East Scotland Region)

Candidates

Michael Charlton Michael Charlton
(Also number 7 on North East Scotland list)
liberal logo
Liberal Democrat
Michael Charlton was born in County Durham in England. He came to Dundee to study at Dundee University and after graduating, remained in the city where he lives with his partner Claire. He works in the West End and, apart from being Secretary of Dundee Liberal Democrats, he is a volunteer for the Red Cross and a supporter of Amnesty International.

Recent electoral experience
2005 Westminster election, Glenrothes, 2,651 votes (7.09 %)
Belinda Don Belinda Don
(Also number 8 on North East Scotland list)
Con logo
Conservative & Unionist
Belinda Don is married with two children. She is Parliamentary Assistant to Struan Stevenson MEP and also works with her husband in their company supplying business news from around the world. She helped organise the last Tory European Election campaign and stood in Glenrothes in 2005.

Recent electoral experience.
2005 Westminster election, Glenrothes, 2,651 votes (7.09 %)
Joe FitzPatrick Cllr Joe FitzPatrick
(Not standing on North East Scotland list)
SNP logo
Scottish National Party
Joe FitzPatrick was born on 1st April 1967 in Dundee and was educated at Whitfield High School in the city.
Joe left Dundee to work for the Forestry Commission in Angus and studied Forestry at Inverness College where he was elected as the first sabbatical President of the Students Union. Joe went on to be elected NUS Convener for the North of Scotland Area which stretched from Dundee to Shetland.
Returning to Dundee Joe continued his education at Abertay University and graduated with a first class honours Degree in science.
Joe works as an assistant to Shona Robison MSP and Stewart Hosie MP in their Dundee Constituency Office. He was first elected to Dundee City Council in 1999 when he overturned a large Labour majority and was re-elected with an increased majority in 2003. In 2005 Joe stood for the SNP in Dundee West at the General Election slashing Labour's majority in half.
A well respected, hardworking local councillor, Joe is the SNP group Whip and Finance Spokesperson on Dundee Council.
Determined to win Dundee West for the SNP, Joe is not standing for re-election to the council or on the regional list.

Recent electoral experience
2005 Westminster election, Dundee West, 11,089 votes (30.02 %) (achieved a swing of 4 % from Labour)
2003 - Election agent for Shona Robison MSP who gained Dundee East from Labour's John McAllion (MP for Dundee East 1987 - 2001 and MSP for Dundee East 1999 - 2003)
2003 Local Council election, Dundee, Longhaugh, 851 votes (51.48 %) (elected with an increased majority) (Re elected as SNP group Whip)
1999 Dundee City Council election, Longhaugh, 997 votes (49.55 %) (elected) (Elected as Whip for the SNP Group)
Kate Maclean MSP Cllr Jill Shimi
(Not standing on North East Scotland list)
labour logo
Labour
Cllr Jill Shimi has been the councillor for Lochee West since 1999, and like her predecessor Kate Maclean, she is leader of Dundee City Council. In October 2006, the Evening Telegraph revealed that under Shimi's administration: "Dundonians are among the least enthusiastic when it comes to voluntary work, training for work, having access to the Internet or saving money. Surprisingly for the city, which has developed a reputation for being the best local authority in Scotland for recycling, the report revealed that less glass, plastic and metal is recycled in the city compared to any other council area. The report also contains some comparisons with other local authority areas that reinforce the difficulties Dundee is experiencing in shaking off its poverty-stricken image. As a result, perhaps, Dundonians' opinion of the city as a place to live is among the lowest of the 32 Scottish council areas." Cllr Shimi's attempts to prevent people donating money to charities has earned her the nickname of 'The Wicked Witch of the West'.

Council Positions:
Leader of Dundee City Council

Recent electoral experience
2003 Dundee City Council election, Lochee West, 856 votes, (53.33 %) (elected)
1999 Dundee City Council election, Lochee West, 1,032 votes, (51.47 %) (elected)

Constituency profile

Assessment:

This assessment is based on the 2003 election results

Rank on Scottish National Party hit list: 5 (1 in 2003)
Swing required for Scottish National Party gain: 2.13 % from Labour to Scottish National Party

Rank on Liberal Democrat hit list: 15 (12 in 2003)
Swing required for Liberal Democrat gain: 12.71 % from Labour to Liberal Democrat

Rank on Conservative hit list: 30 (26 in 2003)
Swing required for Conservative gain: 13.74 % from Labour to Conservative

Correlation to the new Westminster constituencies

The electorate of 54,424 was split between the new Westminster constituencies of:
Dundee West: 52,929 (97.3 %)
Dundee East: 1,495 (2.8 %)

Local Government wards in the constituency

Council Ward number Ward name Electorate (June 2001)
Dundee 1Ninewells3,792
2Camperdown3,871
3Balgay3,976
4Lochee West3,536
5Riverside4,103
6Brackens4,030
7Ardler3,003
8Balgowan3,852
19Strathmartine3,774
20Lochee East3,822
21Tay Bridges4,373
22Logie3,445
23Law3,811
26Hilltown 14,054
27Bowbridge 23,597

1 mostly Dundee East, some Dundee West
2 mostly Dundee West, some Dundee East

Previous results

1 st May 2003 Holyrood Election - Constituency result

Electorate 51,387. Turnout 25,003, 48.66 % (- 3.53 %)
Logo Party Candidate Votes % % change
Labour logo Labour Kate MacLean MSP 8,234 32.93 % - 4.64 %
SNP logo Scottish National Party Irene McGugan MSP 7,168 28.67 % - 8.48 %
Ind Independent Cllr Ian Borthwick 4,715 18.86 % (+ 18.86 %)
Liberal logo Liberal Democrat Shona Ferrier 1,878 7.51 % - 2.80 %
SSP logo Scottish Socialist Party Jim McFarland 1,501 6.00 % + 2.53 %
Con logo Conservative Victoria Roberts 1,376 5.50 % - 6.00 %
SPA logo Scottish Peoples Alliance Morag MacLechan 131 0.52 % (+ 0.52 %)
Labour hold Labour majority 1,066 4.26 % + 3.84 %

1 st May 2003 Holyrood Election - Regional list result

Electorate 51,387. Turnout 24,928, 48.51 %
200 rejected ballot papers
Logo Party Votes%% change
Labour logo Labour 8,361 33.54 % - 2.90 %
SNP logo Scottish National Party 7,381 29.61 % - 5.27 %
Con logo Conservative & Unionist Party 2,173 8.72 % - 2.62 %
Liberal logo Liberal Democrats 2,099 8.42 % - 0.66 %
Scot Soc logo Scottish Socialist Party 1,957 7.85 % + 5.18 %
Scot Green logo Scottish Green Party 1,225 4.91 % + 1.85 %
Pensioners Pensioners' Party 876 3.51 % (+ 3.51 %)
Soc Lab logo Socialist Labour Party 410 1.64 % - 0.45 %
Fishing Party The Fishing Party 200 0.80 % (+ 0.80 %)
UKIP UK Independence Party 124 0.50 % (+ 0.50 %)
SPA Scottish Peoples Alliance 70 0.28 % (+ 0.28 %)
Ind Steven Mathers (Independent) 56 0.22 % (+ 0.22 %)
Lab logo Labour majority 980 3.93 % + 2.37 %

6 th May 1999 Holyrood Election - Constituency result

LogoPartyCandidateVotes%% change
Labour logo Labour Cllr Kate MacLean 10,925 37.57 % - 16.22 %
SNP logo Scottish National Party Calum Cashley 10,804 37.15 % + 13.92 %
Con logo Conservative & Unionist Gordon Buchan 3,345 11.50 % - 1.65 % %
Liberal logo Liberal Democrat Dr Elizabeth Dick 2,998 10.31 % + 2.65 %
Scot Soc logo Scottish Socialist Party Jim McFarlane 1,010 3.47 % + 2.37 %
Labour win Labour majority 121 0.42 % - 30.14 %

6 th May 1999 Holyrood Election - Regional list result

LogoPartyVotes%
Labour logo Labour 10,503 36.44 %
SNP logo Scottish National Party 10,148 34.88 %
Con logo Conservative & Unionist Party 3,299 11.34 %
Liberal logo Liberal Democrats 2,641 9.08 %
Scot Green logo Scottish Green Party 891 3.06 %
Scot Soc logo Scottish Socialist Party 777 2.67 %
Soc Lab logo Socialist Labour Party 607 2.09 %
Nat Law logo Natural Law Party 80 0.27 %
Ind Sleaze Buster 36 0.12 %
Ind Hamish Watt0 ? 0.0 % ?
Labour logo Labour majority 455 1.56 %

1 st May 1997 Westminster Election

LogoPartyCandidateVotes%
Labour logo Labour Ernie Ross MP 20,875 53.79 %
SNP logo Scottish National Party John Dorward 9,016 23.23 %
Con logo Conservative & UNionist Cllr Neil Powrie 5,105 13.15 %
Liberal logo Liberal Democrat Elizabeth Dick 2,972 7.66 %
Scottish Socialist Alliance Mary Ward 428 1.10 %
Referendum logo Referendum John MacMillan 411 1.06 %
Labour hold Labour majority 11,859 30.56 %

Links


Return to home page